Home       Voices       News       Past News       Videos       Books       Action       Donate       Submissions       Mission       Links
  All | Economic | Environment | Health | Middle East | Palestine | Police State | Politics | Science | Zionism | Writers | Advertise

Voices

02/13/07

Permalink 07:53:57 pm, Categories: Voices, 1354 words    

Desperation in Pine Ridge

Melanie McBee


Pine Ridge Indian Reservation photo by Aaron Huey

I am a 27 yr. old Oglala Lakota woman, originally from the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. I was fortunate enough to have been adopted by a stable, Christian family who had my best interests at heart. Most children from Pine Ridge are not so blessed. Pine Ridge is situated in the southwest corner of South Dakota, and is the eighth largest reservation in the United States. The unemployment rate is 85% and 97% of the population are living below the federal poverty level. The infant mortality rate is five times the United States national average, and has among the shortest life expectancies of any group in the western hemisphere.

Alcoholism, addiction, violence, and suicide predominate in this once tranquil place. Although my family educated me on the statistics, I was hardly prepared when in 1997-98, I went to live there. I was mortified by the alcoholism. These people...MY PEOPLE were committing a slow suicide by the huge amounts of alcohol they were consuming. This was no longer just another statistic to me; it became my reality, the place I woke up to every day. Many of these families are living without necessities like running water, electricity, sewer, heat--even food, diapers, and formula. Despite these things--they somehow always seem to find the money to drink, or to buy a can of hair spray to huff, or a can of paint to sniff.

My people are stealing from each other to drink, committing burglaries to drink, and begging for money from others to be able to buy just one can of beer. I have a brother who was also under foster care off of the reservation, and at 7 yrs. old the tribe came and took him back, so he was then forced to live on the reservation with his Indian family. When I chose to live there, I became very close with him. He told me that he wished that I would leave, because it would be better than to subject myself to the lifestyle on the reservation. He expressed deep seated regret that he was carelessly pulled from a financially, spiritually, and emotionally stable home and returned to the reservation. He did everything in his power to make me miserable when I lived there, so that I would just leave. He was robbed of the wonderful opportunities he could have had. Why - Racism. My nation would rather force the children to continue to live with instability, alcoholism, and violence, than to have them adopted by the “whites.”

Being a sovereign nation, nothing can be done through state social services--and the government doesn't want anything to do with us, unless, of course, it is to make themselves look good. The tribe will cast an alcoholic into treatment, based on another alcoholic’s word--but they will not remove an obviously neglected child from their cockroach infested home. I firsthand, have witnessed my blood, my family, the future generation of children--being abused physically, and emotionally. These children are not being given even a fighting chance of a beginning in life.

This past summer, the same brother I mentioned telephoned me in a drunken stupor, and told me that if I didn't come and get him, he was going to commit suicide. I had two other close family members commit suicide, of course I decided I needed to go and help him. At 2:00 am, my husband and I loaded up our two small children, and what we would need into our van, and we left from Minnesota to Martin, South Dakota to pick up my brother. Upon arrival, the first thing we observed was the housing, which horrified my husband, and reminded me of the desolation of my people.

My baby nieces were crying because they were hungry, their diapers had not been changed in what had to have been a day, they were dirty, and running around with no shoes on, despite the glass on the ground--they had no clothes on, and had a look of utter misery, and bewilderment on their little precious faces. YET their mothers were in the back yard drinking at ten in the morning. NO CHILD should have to live this way--I just wanted to take these children, and bring them home, but I couldn't---what's worse, these children will grow up believing that the things that they witness, and endure are normal. I was powerless to do anything for these children--I wanted to embrace them, and take them home with me.

Upon finding my brother, we also found a house full of my drunken relatives. My granddaughter (in Native custom) whom was a little older than my own baby of 6 months, was crawling around with no clothes, shoes, and a horribly soiled diaper--with cockroaches, dirt, cigarette ashes, and beer cans on the floor--narrowly avoiding being stepped on. The baby's mother who is my niece is 16, and drunk right along with everyone else. For them, this lifestyle is completely commonplace.

I know of children 5years old, molesting 3 month old babies--fathers molesting children, mothers molesting children--every form of incest there is, has, and will continue to take place there-- I have watched family members die of alcohol poisoning, or cirrhosis--I've watched them have to have limbs removed because of their irresponsibility in taking care of their diabetic needs--because they would rather concentrate on where their next beer is coming from, or who can get meth, or a gun.

When I first went there at 16 to visit, everyone was so excited to meet me, and then they started telling me that I didn't belong there, because I wasn't really a true Native, because I was raised with white people. Then they told me that I didn't belong with my white family, that I belonged there with them. I was called an "apple" red on the outside, and white on the inside, to them I was, and still am--a wannabe Native. The racism, even against their own, is unbelievable.

Men, beating their women are a normal occurrence here, as are beatings and stabbings amongst family. A majority of these things can be directly linked to alcohol--yet there's an liquor store in downtown Martin and gas stations that sell liquor. There is Whiteclay, Nebraska selling liquor just off reservation boundaries. Natives, knowing full well the alcoholism rate, are selling alcohol to their own. I have seen people call the tribal police on someone for liquor violation, just to sneak alcohol into their own house.

There are dirty tribal police that have raped women that they were supposed to be taking to the tribal jail, or offer to not take them to jail for sexual favors. These things constitute every day life on the reservation, and although these things happen in other places, I believe that the plight of my people should take precedence over the third world countries the government is claiming to help.

I mean, President Bush is claiming to be spending all these millions of dollars of YOUR money, to help the situations in third world countries---when for all practical purposes he is creating a situation, a problem in addition to the country's previous problems, and furthermore Bush is the President of THIS country--NOT anywhere else. Then shouldn't the problems here in the United States be addressed first?

You see this month is black history month, and other times, you see that there is some “awareness day” for something but, Native American Day goes widely ignored, and there is no awareness day, or month, or even a second for the plight of the Native Americans. This is my mission, to educate people about the reservation, and to let my voice be heard, to be the voice for the suffering children on the reservation, for my noble ancestors, and to start doing something about the desolation which is Pine Ridge Indian Reservation.

-###-

Feuary 13, 2007 © Copyright February 13, 2007 by Melanie McBee, a Native American. Permission is granted for reprint in print, email, blog, or web media if this credit is attached and the title remains unchanged.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: icw [Member]
While I understand your frustration, I'm afriad people are going to read this and assume all Native people are alcoholic child abusers. This is not the case. Some reservations have more social issues than others, some are much worse off than others. Please don't give the world the impression that there is nothing positive at Pine Ridge and there are not people there that aren't trying to improve things.
The things you are describing need to be refered to whomever handles child protective services for the tribe. The tribe has laws against this and has a system to protect these children. If the child protective services program is not contacted with this information, it is going to be hard for them to do anything. Additionally, child protective services (tribal or state) need to catch the abuse/neglect in proximity to the time it happened if the child won't dislose it. Indian or not, most abused/neglected kids don't report it.
I would also like to address the fact that a federal justice program reviewed crime data across racial lines, and found that Native people have the highest rates of victimization (assauts, domestic violence, murder) by other races out of all ethnic groups. Native people are more likely to be victimized by non-Indians according to federal crime data.
I also think it is misleading to say that any tribe would prefer for children to be in abuse/neglect scenarios than adopted by whites. I'm sure if you checked with your tribe's Indian Child Welfare program, you would find a very large number of children are placed in white foster homes with tribal approval. There are not enough Native foster homes available for all the Native children in foster care. If you are aware of ICW custody children placed in a neglectful/abusive foster home you should make this known to the ICW program. There are plenty of good white foster homes out there. However, there is an extremely large number of Native children who have had bad experiences being adopted out to non-Indian families, and their experiences have left them with on-going identity and psychological issues. There are white people abuse and neglect children, too.
I feel bad that you have had negative experiences returning to your people, particularly around being accepted. This often happens to all Native people who have been raised off the reservation, whether they were adopted or if their family moved away. The reservation is a very tight knit place, and it takes time to be accepted if you have been away. I am not trying to invalidate your points or feelings, but I feel the need to make sure there is a balanced picture of Indian Country. The negative is all most outsiders hear. Many tribes have excellent social services programs, and do great jobs at protecting their children. Federal funding of child welfare programs serving Indian country are hurrendously underfunded, and don't have enough staff to keep up with the cases despite those workers putting their heart and soul into it.
I also fear that people may read this and use it to attack the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). ICWA gives tribes the right to intervene in state child welfare cases involving tribal children. It also gives them the ability to pursue transfer of these cases to tribal courts. Many people assume that the tribe can automatically transfer the case. However, both of the child's parents can object to this transfer, as can a child by requesting it stay in state court. ICWA requires state courts to follow placement preference guidelines as well. Relatives (Indian or not, and preference is not given to placement with an Indian relative) are to be considered first, then members of the child's tribe, then other Indian homes, then Non-Indians. Of course, the court is responsible to make sure these homes are safe. If a child is placed into an unsafe home, this is the fault of the judge.
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 08:55
Comment from: talkingwolf [Member]
Melanie, Pilamaya for your article. Although I am not Lakota but I am Native. I have been to Pine Ridge a long time ago (1970). Perhaps if someone were to start, as you seem to want to do, to get the Elders and the Wicasa Wakan, Winyan Wakan, Pejuta Wicasa and the Pejuta Winyan to all stand together at one time in the same place and say, "NO MORE" because you are right, the government of this country doesn't care nor does the general public. Indians are nice to watch and to a great extent emulate (to the extent a book or movie protrays them) but no one really wants to do anything. I have tried for a long time and have gotten some of the same treatment you have. I have been called a wannabe, apple or fake because I am not federally registered. Pine Ridge is not the only reservation that has those problems and just as bad. Perhaps Indians all over the country might want to start looking at themselves as Indians rather than in a singular since as Lakota, Choctaw, Crow, Cheyenne, etc but Indians. Native People. We, them, you, cannot depend on a government go give pride, self respect or even hope. That will have to come from within. For me, being Indian is knowing my connection with the Sacred Circle of Life. It was not easy and will not be easy but it can be done. I walked away from alcohol and drugs over 30 years ago. It was through that connection that I was able to do so. Every morning when I pray, my first prayer is for the Creator of all things to bless the Indian people and give them stength and heart.
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 08:57
Comment from: Proud Rez Winyan [Member]
Melanie, you can consider yourself a very fortunate person to be a good foster home, my brother & myself were not very fortunate, we were placed in foster care in a white foster home in a white town. We were not placed in foster care cause of neglect or abuse, but this is what we endured while in foster care. My mother had major surgery and there was no extended family to care for us. I was raised in Pierre, SD and attended school there from first to seventh grade and this was also more abuse from the white society, the majority of native kids lived in East Pierre and we had to walk in a pack cause if we walked alone we were jumped by the white kids. Not all native homes are like you describe, but I'm use to the stereo type. I use to say I was racist against the white society because my brother was murdered in Chamberlain, SD while he was on leave from the military on my mothers birthday and this murder was covered up by this town. But now my son/nephew is married to a non-indian and she is a very special person to our family and I love her and look at her as a blessing from Jesus to help me overcome my stupidity. Yes our people suffer from alcoholism, drug addiction and sexual abuse and I can go on and on why they do, the majority is our grandparents endured horrible treatment from boarding schools and humiliated by white caretakers many were beaten, sexually abused by both male and female, starved. And this cycle of abuse is yet to be broken. So can you honestly say this only happens on indian reservations? Is the white society clean of this? I think not! I commend you on your comments of the Bush Administration our People need Treatment facilities for Meth, Jail facilities, School Buildings, Police Officers. With all the cut backs from the Government our Tribes are suffering. We did once have noble ancestors who protected the people but the white man's alcohol and drugs took this away. Good luck Melanie on your mission, but there has been many people who tried and are still trying what you want.
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 10:34
Comment from: mom of nine [Member]
Bless you Melanie!
I have seen the same things you have and agree.

And part of the reason these things continue and continue can be seen in the blogs above - It's not just about white people ignoring it. Too many tribal members themselves continue to believe 'it's not so bad" and "it's no different in the white world." Yes, it is different. There are bad things happening all over the world. But the reservations have a huge, huge concentration of suffering children, and simply saying that the same type of thing happens everywhere doesn't help the children it is happening to.

That sttitude is simply a denial of the horrible things happening to huge number of children living in Indian Country. The tribal extablishment, itself, is turning it's back on the situation and pretending it's not there. "If we say it's not a monsterous problem, it will disappear." "See no evil, speak no evil, hear no evil." and "it's all the white man's fault."

And while the first writer is correct that ICWA is intended to be used in the way she describes, many times it is not. Birth parents are frequently denied the right to keep their children out of tribal court, and non-tribal relatives are frequently ignored. Story after story of these types of cases can be read on ...

http://www.caicw.org/familystories.html

By the way, your story is posted there now, as well, with full credits.

It's time people stop pretending that these problems aren't there and that they are not deadly serious.

Bless you again, Melanie
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 11:16
Comment from: CedarElkWoman [Member]
I feel the need to point out that adoption is not always, as the author points out, a happy story with a happy ending. I was adopted out to white "Christian" parents, who abused me so severely I am still attempting to recover - decades after escaping their home at age 15. Needless to say, they lied about my ethnicity, and I learned nothing (from THEM) about my heritage. Fortunately, I am very Spiritual, I am on the Red Road, and I have incredible people from Pine Ridge helping me Spiritually, and healing me Spiritually. However, the horrors of being in an abusive family do not stop at the Rez borders. European Americans - Christian, upper middle class, and all of the appearances of providing a good home and family, can in actuality be severely abusive to vulnerable children with no means of escape. All of the European doctors say that it is "impossible" that I am still alive. I feel that we must work on traditional ways of taking care of children, and not adopting our children out to Europeans, where it is a tremendous gamble with a child's life, and guaranteed to NOT teach these children our ways. I for one believe that I have a responsibility to help children remain in our ways and be free from abuse. Mitakuye Oyasin, Hante Unpan Winyan, Cedar Elk Woman
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 12:59
Comment from: icw [Member]
In regards to CHRISTIAN ALLIANCE FOR INDIAN CHILD WELFARE...of which "Mom of Nine" gives a link to...

They are not a reliable source in regards to the Indian Child Welfare Act. They are a special interest group founded by several Ojibway who are disgruntled with their tribe and have gone on a mission to basically have ICWA abolished as well as tribal sovereignty due to personal issues they have with their tribe. They don't seem to care that they are jeoperdising sovereignty of tribes, nor do they seem to care that most children benefit dramatically due to ICWA's existence. Rather than focus on correcting problems in their own tribe, they have set out to cause problems for all U.S. tribes.

In reading the stories posted on their page, the cases I'm reading are cases often attacking ICWA due to bad tribal court rulings. I'd like to explain something. ICWA is a law that mandates states, not tribes. Tribal courts are not bound by the Indian Child Welfare Act, only states are. People get all upset over a tribal court ruling and blame it on ICWA, when ICWA has nothing to do with it. I feel very strongly about this as a tribal child welfare worker for the past 7 years. If a tribal court makes a bad ruling that is not reason to attack ICWA. If a tribal court is not following it's own rules, there are appeals processes, these cases can be appealed federally. Instead of educating themselves on this, people focus on ICWA and ignore the fact that the vast majority of the time ICWA has a positive result for the kids. If state courts are not following ICWA, don't blame ICWA. Blame that specific judge and court.

And please please please, don't take CHRISTIAN ALLIANCE FOR INDIAN CHILD WELFARE as an expert source. Please contact the National Indian Child Welfare Association www.nicwa.org , which is a private organization that educates tribes, states, and private organizations on child welfare issues in Indian country. They are a very respected national organization, and are making a big difference.
Permalink 02/14/07 @ 13:27
Comment from: DBailey [Member]
I am so hurt by this story! I am a Native American from the Flandreau Santee Sioux Tribe and I am also the first Foster Parent for this Tribe. I am also registered through the state of SD. I know the ICWA Laws and agree with all of them. I have adopted a 16 yr. old Native American boy from the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation and in some situations, childred do have to be in WHITE homes because there are no Native American Foster Families. I have had all nationalities in my Foster home. I would LOVE to be here for ALL of those children who need someone to care for them. IF I am needed, contact me by my e-mail. These children need LOVE! God Bless the little children, Diane
Permalink 02/16/07 @ 09:30
Comment from: bobinthebox [Member]
Dear Melanie,

My heart and my light go out to you and your people, who are one with us, no matter their origon. Humanity is all one family and unfortunately, not everyone is hooked up to this truth, yet.

We humans, have been living a lie for many centuries now. When a lie is born, ceaseless strategies are employed by the liars to obsfuctae reality thus creating the illusionary world we live in. This experiment in duality, choosing between positive and negative vibrations, is about to come to an end. Much Karma has been built up upon this Mother Gaia starship for eons of time and now she is in the midst of cleansing it all from her conscious reality. She is alive and in great pain and has been allowed to ascend in vibration, to heaven. As we are a part of her spirit, we also are ascending but alas many ones will choose to remain behind during this period, which only arrives every few thousand years. We must let them go and with our love and light bless them and pray they see the light sooner rather than later. That's all we can do. Each one must find their own truths, which will put them back upon the path to light. Each has their own lessons to learn, in their time, not yours. We can offer up our spiritual wisdom and share our bounty with them, helping them up. This is a universal continual goal of all spirits, toward others. What affects one, affects all.

The lying strategies employed throughout all our systems have served the dark forces and enabling them mastery over our daily lives. Their lives manipulate and pollute us as their goal is depopulation and total control of all economies and systems under one, "New World Order". Of course this flies in the face of all of God's laws. In fact, God's laws are ignored in favor of man's laws, which are instituted as strategies to continue the lies. Hence, the illusion we are dealing with.

The confines of reservations only serve to reinforce seperation. Racial divide is a great weapon used by the dark ones to keep us from the reality that we are all one, just as they keep the religious truths of Esu Immanuel Sananda (Jesus) from us. They have twisted the lies in order to keep us from awakening to our powers within. We the people, when together, even just thinking together, have immense powers to change the illusion back to reality. The discoveries awaiting all of us will boggle our minds and release us, finally, from the dark forces, we volunteered to succumb to.

Tell your Indian family that they are all a part of the one creator source, as so are we all. Explain that the book of reincarnation was left out of the bible explicitly to lead us down the wrong paths. Let me explain that statement this way. You have to be it, to learn it and the soul retains all wisdom gained from all life experiences. We are all on differing levels of lives and wisdom gained and those obviously with less wisdom need to be helped up by the others. But you cannot get a deaf man to listen. He/she must want to progress or they will miss ascension, this time around. They will have to remain in a 3-D world for more time until they choose the path to light and awaken their spirit, to who they truly are.

Melanie, refer the tribal leaders to www.fourwinds10.com where they will find the Phoenix Journals. God promised us the dissemination of the truth, once again before returning. They will find all needed materials there. It is for them to teach their people where the path to truth and light is and return to them their meaning of this life so they may reap the love and happiness they all deserve. All there is, is Love. They are all in my prayers and I will continue to send out my light, as we are all the lightkeepers, volunteered to be here at this historic time. And so it is. ^j^
Permalink 02/16/07 @ 13:18
Comment from: icw [Member]
"The confines of reservations only serve to reinforce seperation."

Reservations are often refered to as prisons, but Reservations are often places of strength. Assimilation is not a goal of Native people, and reservations are often cultural strongholds. In many ways they don't keep us locked in, they keep cultures that seek to terminate us at bay. If our reservations were abolished, our people would be worse off.

This is more of the misunderstandings of our people, culturally and politically.
Permalink 02/16/07 @ 14:46
Comment from: TurtleMolester [Member]
Dear Melanie, Not Everyone On The Rez Is Broke Like You, I Have Been Living On The Rez Since I Was Born. And Ur Ugly. And Smell Funny. I Make 30 Bucks An Hour. And I Live On The Rez, Wut Do U Make? Thats Right...I Said 30...Wuts Up.

P.S. My Turtle Says Wuts Up
Permalink 03/01/07 @ 10:20
Comment from: TurtleMolester [Member]
G Unit!
Permalink 03/01/07 @ 10:20
Comment from: TurtleMolester [Member]
G Unit Bitch!
Permalink 03/01/07 @ 10:25
Comment from: Priscilla Herrera [Member]
Dear Melanie,
Unfortunately, there are many issues on the reservations. I come from a family of "strong" Native women. We will not take a handout and my family have always worked to survive. You alone cannot change these issues. I attend a college where there are many intelligent Native Americans, their critical thinking never ceases to amaze me. These Natives have Master's degrees and many are working on their Doctorate's. They are aware of these issues and are getting educated so they can go back to their reservations to help their people through awareness. Your approach to this is rather insulting. My children are racially mixed and I expose them to their Native people and their father's African American community. I also went to high school with many Native American foster students and they used to be so ashamed of their own people. You cannot expect the whites to fix every little problem we face. We just need to educate, stand together and become a strong society instead of trying to get Mr. Bush to help us. He doesn't give a damn about us!
Permalink 08/03/07 @ 16:33
Comment from: bred2_h8 [Member]
mel oh mel now lets be real, we as natives oddly off the rez need to watch our tounges, ever hear the term hear no evil??? well tell you the truth, all that you see is going on in the us also even worse in lower class neighbor hoods look how skinny and melnourished your friends look and oh indians eat we aren't one of the leading diabetic races for nothing we eat and eat good pow wows sundances birthdays holidays weekends summertimes late at nite even the munchies, so if you sit here and keep pushin this save the indian shit you'll never really experiance life, you'll be to busy bout wat their doing and you need to understand people will be people, maybe they like it, and really i mean like it that much where it comes first, i know i drink for my enjoyment, why not save the irish go join the peace corp hoola at ya in south america mel...
Permalink 09/18/07 @ 06:24
Comment from: bred2_h8 [Member]
i'm a proud oglala lakota sioux, i was born in wambli on the pine ridge indian rez.i'm from a strong,proud native family with a stong lakota mother who raised me,My name is Patrick...i've heard your story and i'm happy you found a good home,we are proud we still have a portion of our land,and we'll not give it up for christianity or anything else.....we still practice our traditional ways, and if you really wanted to help your tribe you would push our children to learn our dying language and traditional way of life,
Good luck to you but my children are gonna learn it...
Permalink 09/18/07 @ 18:29
Comment from: Jtothe [Member]
I like you am a Oglala Lakota, but unlike you I am actually proud of it. I know where you are coming from, I see many people like you who are embarrassed about the statistics coming out of Pine Ridge, and it is very true what you say it is nothing to be proud of.
There are things about being Lakota that you can be proud of though. Like the fact that even through all the crap our people have went through we still hold onto our traditional ways and our language.
I used to be like you and be embarrassed to be Indian but that got me nowhere. My parents both went to college, they are both from Pine Ridge, we moved off of the reservation so that they could get better jobs. I have never lived on the rez but I am moving back for school, I want to learn our language and more of our culture. I want to help with whatever I can.
Instead of writing such terrible things why not be the change you wish to see? Why not sign up to be a foster parent? Why not be proud of your people for what is there to be proud of? Why go the route of being negative?
Your blog may raise attention to some serious issues that need to be addressed but it also attaches more of a negative stigma to our people that really isn't needed or necessary.
Permalink 08/07/09 @ 19:21





Search the Site Search the Internet




Just Foreign Policy Iraqi Death Estimator



Newsletter

Enter Your E-mail:

Posts by day of the Month

March 2010
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
<<  <   >  >>
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        

Search

Syndicate this blog XML

What is RSS?

thepeoplesvoice.org

FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted articles and information about environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. This news and information is displayed without profit for educational purposes, in accordance with, Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Thepeoplesvoice.org is a non-advocacy internet web site, edited by non-affiliated U.S. citizens. editor

Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS! Valid RSS! Valid Atom! b2evolution