« Turkey Targets Press FreedomNew York Times v. Hugo Chavez »

"I told you so..."

March 12th, 2013

By Michael Collins
 photo eikenberry_zps48f9dc44.jpg
General Karl W. Eikenberry was right in November 2009 when he urged less support for an Afghanistan ruled by President Hamid Karzai. President Obama and Generals Stanley McChrystal and David Petraeus all wanted a surge. The policy failed. The general won't say it but he told them so in a second opinion solicited by Obama. Look at the facts. (Image)

The Bush administration hand-picked Hamid Karzai to be the first ruler of Afghanistan. Following the axiom, nothing good comes out of the Bush administration; is it any surprise that Karzai oscillated between less than effective and a near disaster? Lately, he's gone nonlinear.

On February 25, Karzai ordered United States Special Forces out of three provinces claiming that Afghan troops tied to the U.S. command were torturing their fellow citizens. As U.S. Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel arrived in Kabul on March 11, Karzai accused the U.S. of "colluding with the Taliban." He added the odd notion that the Taliban sought a prolonged U.S. presence in Afghanistan.

Retired Army colonel David Maxwell of Georgetown University remarked: “I cannot see how we could work with such an apparently delusional leader much longer, but unfortunately I do not know if we have any other good options.” Bloomberg, Mar 11

It didn't have to be this way.

In late 2009, the Obama administration finalized its review of Afghanistan policy. There were two diametrically opposed choices. General Stanley McChrystal argued for a dramatic increase in troops, focusing on Special Forces. He assured the president that his plan would work given enough resources. Disgraced General David Petraeus leaked the McChrystal plan to put leverage on Obama, who was already in favor of a surge. The policy of a troop surge prevailed but there was another choice, one backed by experience and evidence.

General David Eikenberry, at the time, the U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan, argued just the opposite in a cable to the president before the decision. He noted that Karzai lacked legitimacy with the people of Afghanistan. Popular support and a degree of public trust were the baseline requirements for any stabilization and successful U.S. withdrawal.

"WASHINGTON — The United States ambassador to Afghanistan, who once served as the top American military commander there, has expressed in writing his reservations about deploying additional troops to the country, three senior American officials said Wednesday.

"The position of the ambassador, Karl W. Eikenberry, puts him in stark opposition to the current American and NATO commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal, who has asked for 40,000 more troops." New York Times, Nov. 11

Eikenberry knew Karzai and he knew the election that brought him to power was rigged. He didn't figure this out after the fact. As U.S. Ambassador, Eikenberry went public demanding a clean election. He went so far as to appear with opposition candidate, Abdullah Abdullah, at campaign rallies where he called for a free and fair election. His clear message was not heeded. The first round of voting in August 2009 was so corrupt, candidate Abdullah pulled out of the final vote. There was no point, he said.

An unfair election denies the victor political legitimacy. The challenges facing Afghanistan required a legitimate leader (alternate link). The lack of legitimacy plus Karzai's sketchy past and associations meant ultimate failure for any U.S. effort.

Had the administration followed the general's advice, we would not be dealing with a delusional Karzai today.

Public servants like General Eikenberry represent the opportunity for real change. People of integrity and demonstrated courage need to be heard. When they have a record of achievement and firsthand knowledge of the facts on the ground, their advice should prevail. In this case, that process failed. The question remains. Will the administration learn the folly of endless wars?

END

This article may be reproduced with attribution of authorship and a link to this article.

How we got to Zero: General Eikenberry's Hail Mary by Michael Collins, November 12, 2009

 

No feedback yet

Voices  Share this page

Voices

  • Katherine Watt [07/23/23] Orientation for new readers As I read and write more about pre- and post-1959 Catholic teaching as they relate to current geopolitical events, I want to emphasize that I’m on a learning curve, and my views are developing as my…
  • Katherine Watt [07/29/23] Orientation for new readers Excellent new post by Sasha Latypova on Dec. 10, 1974 National Security Study Memorandum 200 ■ July 26, 2023 - Population Control Policy. Why would my government want to kill me? Don't they…
  • PressTV The Israeli genocide against Palestinians in Gaza is funded by the United States according to Joe Iosbaker, an American political analyst and a leader of the Anti-War Committee – Chicago. 💬 “The US government leads the world in many…
  • Dr. Halvor Næss [06/17/23] It is now more than three years since the covid-19 pandemic started, and two almost self-evident statements summarize the most important lessons learned. 1. Without the draconian handling of the authorities, the pandemic would…
  • Dr Vernon Coleman If you want to know the truth about vaccines and vaccinations please read my book Anyone who tells you vaccines are safe and effective is lying: Here’s the truth. You can find it for sale on Amazon. 1. The UK is now sending long range…
  • Cesare Sacchetti When Donald Trump in 2016 walked down the mobile stairs of his New York residence, the Trump Tower, many prominent members of the deep state were anguished by a feeling of both panic and fear. Panic because for the first time after the…
  • Jeff Thomas The decline from democracy to tyranny is both a natural and inevitable one. That’s not a pleasant thought to have to consider, but it’s a fact, nonetheless. In every case, a democracy will deteriorate as the result of the electorate…
  • Walter Gelles Legal trickery would silence Dr. Charles Hoffe Prominent Canadian physician Dr. Charles Hoffe has spoken out courageously to warn people of the very serious dangers of the Covid mRNA genetic "vaccines". He now faces trial from the Canadian…
  • Stephen Lendman [04/05/23][Stephen died on May 9th, 2023, about a month after he wrote this article.] Illegitimately installed Biden regime criminals run the empire of lies and forever wars. A previous article discussed Trump’s politicized indictment,…
  • Linh Dinh [Pakse, Laos on 6/5/23] Sherwood Anderson, “For a time he was lonely and wrote to Alice almost every day. Then he was caught up by the life of the city; he began to make friends and found new interests in life.” Why quote a rather plain…
March 2024
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31            

  XML Feeds

free blog tool
FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted articles and information about environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. This news and information is displayed without profit for educational purposes, in accordance with, Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Thepeoplesvoice.org is a non-advocacy internet web site, edited by non-affiliated U.S. citizens. editor
ozlu Sozler GereksizGercek Hava Durumu Firma Rehberi Hava Durumu Firma Rehberi E-okul Veli Firma Rehberi